Skip to content
  • Home
  • Shop All
  • Brands
    • All That Chocolate
    • Alpha Importers
    • Avenue 29 Sauces
    • Babcia's Pierogi
    • Baker Farms Garlic Powder
    • Barrel & Brine
    • Battistoni
    • Bean Bastard
    • Biscotti For Everybotti
    • Bloom and Rose Knishes
    • Blue Table Chocolates
    • Burning Asphalt
    • Buffalo Pepper Products
    • Broadway Market Famous Horseradish
    • Carrubba's Chicken Pit
    • Chenez's Popcorn
    • Clarky's Twisted Sauce
    • Cosimano & Ferrari
    • Cuba Cheese Shoppe
    • Cuppa Culture TEApourium
    • Dark Forest Chocolate
    • Deb's Delights
    • Deedee Desserts
    • Donna's Pepper Jelly & Jams
    • Dragonfly Jams and Jellies
    • East Hill Creamery
    • Eden Valley Creamery
    • Fetch Dog Treats
    • Finger Lakes Harvest
    • Gondola Macaroni Products
    • Go Veggies
    • Gramma Mora's Mexican Cuisine
    • Guglielmo's Pasta Sauces
    • Healthy Rican
    • Issa's Pita Chips
    • Jake and the Fatman BBQ
    • Kelly's Country Store Chocolates
    • Keeping Traditions Pierogi
    • Kissed By The Sun Spices
    • Laura's Raw Honey
    • Lewiston's Jams and Jellies
    • Life Itself Chaga Tea
    • Lions Mane Infusions
    • Malezewski Butter Lambs
    • Maple Glen Sugarhouse
    • McDuffie's Bakery
    • Meyer's Homegrown Popcorn
    • M&M Pickles
    • Najah Sauces
    • Nanny Dot's Pantry
    • New Day Coffee
    • New York Chips
    • Niagara Chocolates By Frey
    • Nickel City Alchemy
    • Nickel City Nitro
    • Nick's Spider Venom
    • Nunda Mustard
    • Park Edge Sweet Shop
    • Pasta Peddler
    • Penelope's Dog Treats
    • Pickle Annie's
    • Pizza Plant
    • Salvatores Speciality Foods
    • Smita's Cookery
    • Smoke Shack Jerky
    • Snowy Owl Kombucha
    • So Good Granola
    • Spices by Milly
    • Spoonfuls Nut Butters
    • Sugarcane WNY
    • That Popcorn Shack
    • The Blend Bar
    • Tea-Licious Trendz
    • Ted's Hot Dogs
    • Top Seedz
    • The Sweet Whisk
    • Uncle Bob's BBQ Sauce
    • Weber's Maple Products
    • Weber's Mustard
    • We R Nuts
    • What's Pop-In Gourmet Popcorn
    • Yancey's Fancy
    • Yeah! Vegan Pierogi
  • Categories
    • Buffalo Flavored
    • Chocolates & Desserts
    • Coffee, Teas, & Spices
    • Health & Wellness
    • Hot & Spicy
    • Meats & Cheese
    • Pierogi & Pasta
    • Snacks
    • Spreads, Sauces, & Marinades
    • Staff Picks
    • On Sale
    • Easter Collection
    • Father's Day Collection
  • Gift Sets
  • Retail Locations
  • About
    • Meet The Makers
    • Local Delivery & Shipping
    • Out Story
    • Contact Us
Buffalo Artisan Food Traders
Cart
  • Home
  • Shop All
  • Brands
    • All That Chocolate
    • Alpha Importers
    • Avenue 29 Sauces
    • Babcia's Pierogi
    • Baker Farms Garlic Powder
    • Barrel & Brine
    • Battistoni
    • Bean Bastard
    • Biscotti For Everybotti
    • Bloom and Rose Knishes
    • Blue Table Chocolates
    • Burning Asphalt
    • Buffalo Pepper Products
    • Broadway Market Famous Horseradish
    • Carrubba's Chicken Pit
    • Chenez's Popcorn
    • Clarky's Twisted Sauce
    • Cosimano & Ferrari
    • Cuba Cheese Shoppe
    • Cuppa Culture TEApourium
    • Dark Forest Chocolate
    • Deb's Delights
    • Deedee Desserts
    • Donna's Pepper Jelly & Jams
    • Dragonfly Jams and Jellies
    • East Hill Creamery
    • Eden Valley Creamery
    • Fetch Dog Treats
    • Finger Lakes Harvest
    • Gondola Macaroni Products
    • Go Veggies
    • Gramma Mora's Mexican Cuisine
    • Guglielmo's Pasta Sauces
    • Healthy Rican
    • Issa's Pita Chips
    • Jake and the Fatman BBQ
    • Kelly's Country Store Chocolates
    • Keeping Traditions Pierogi
    • Kissed By The Sun Spices
    • Laura's Raw Honey
    • Lewiston's Jams and Jellies
    • Life Itself Chaga Tea
    • Lions Mane Infusions
    • Malezewski Butter Lambs
    • Maple Glen Sugarhouse
    • McDuffie's Bakery
    • Meyer's Homegrown Popcorn
    • M&M Pickles
    • Najah Sauces
    • Nanny Dot's Pantry
    • New Day Coffee
    • New York Chips
    • Niagara Chocolates By Frey
    • Nickel City Alchemy
    • Nickel City Nitro
    • Nick's Spider Venom
    • Nunda Mustard
    • Park Edge Sweet Shop
    • Pasta Peddler
    • Penelope's Dog Treats
    • Pickle Annie's
    • Pizza Plant
    • Salvatores Speciality Foods
    • Smita's Cookery
    • Smoke Shack Jerky
    • Snowy Owl Kombucha
    • So Good Granola
    • Spices by Milly
    • Spoonfuls Nut Butters
    • Sugarcane WNY
    • That Popcorn Shack
    • The Blend Bar
    • Tea-Licious Trendz
    • Ted's Hot Dogs
    • Top Seedz
    • The Sweet Whisk
    • Uncle Bob's BBQ Sauce
    • Weber's Maple Products
    • Weber's Mustard
    • We R Nuts
    • What's Pop-In Gourmet Popcorn
    • Yancey's Fancy
    • Yeah! Vegan Pierogi
  • Categories
      Categories
    • All
    • Buffalo Flavored
    • Chocolates & Desserts
    • Coffee, Teas, & Spices
    • Health & Wellness
    • Hot & Spicy
    • Meats & Cheese
    • Pierogi & Pasta
    • Snacks
    • Spreads, Sauces, & Marinades
    • Staff Picks
    • On Sale
    • Easter Collection
    • Father's Day Collection
    • Boozy Truffles
      Blue Table Chocolates
      Boozy Truffles
      From $11.99
      View
      Cheese Stuffed Banana Pepper Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
      Keeping Traditions Pierogi
      Cheese Stuffed Banana Pepper Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
      Regular price $11.99
      View
      Divine Goodness
      Spoonfuls Gourmet Nut Butters
      Divine Goodness
      Regular price $7.99
      View
  • Gift Sets
  • Retail Locations
  • About
    • Meet The Makers
    • Local Delivery & Shipping
    • Out Story
    • Contact Us
Item added to cart. View cart and check out.
Store Open 7 Days A Week | Get Free Local Delivery On All Online Orders of $40 Or More!

All That Chocolate

View all

Assorted Truffles
All That Chocolate
Assorted Truffles
Regular price $12.99
View
Milk Chocolate Sea Salted Caramels
All That Chocolate
Milk Chocolate Sea Salted Caramels
Regular price $9.99
View
Milk Chocolate Nut Bark
All That Chocolate
Milk Chocolate Nut Bark
Regular price $11.99
View

Alpha Importers

View all

Balsamic Vinegar
Alpha Importers
Balsamic Vinegar
Regular price $6.99
View
Basil Infused Olive Oil
Alpha Importers
Basil Infused Olive Oil
Regular price $7.49
View
Extra Virgin Olive Oil 1 Liter
Alpha Importers
Extra Virgin Olive Oil 1 Liter
Regular price $15.99
View
Extra Virgin Olive Oil 3 Liter Can
Alpha Importers
Extra Virgin Olive Oil 3 Liter Can
Regular price $35.99
View

Avenue 29 Evolved Foods

View all

Avenue 29 Cilantro Lime Dressing
Avenue 29
Avenue 29 Cilantro Lime Dressing
Regular price $7.49
View
Avenue 29 Lemon Pomegranate Dressing
Avenue 29
Avenue 29 Lemon Pomegranate Dressing
Regular price $7.49
View
Avenue 29 Avocado Lime Sauce
Avenue 29
Avenue 29 Avocado Lime Sauce
Regular price $7.49
View
Avenue 29 Chipotle Aioli
Avenue 29
Avenue 29 Chipotle Aioli
Regular price $7.49
View

Babcia's Pierogi

View all

Stuffed Mushroom Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Babcia's Pierogi
Stuffed Mushroom Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $8.99
View
Potato Mushroom and Bleu Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Babcia's Pierogi
Potato Mushroom and Bleu Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $8.99
View
Potato Jalapeno Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Babcia's Pierogi
Potato Jalapeno Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
Potato Bacon Chive (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Babcia's Pierogi
Potato Bacon Chive (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View

Baker Farms Garlic Powder

View all

Baker Farm's Garlic Powder
Baker Farms
Baker Farm's Garlic Powder
Regular price $9.99
View

Barrel & Brine

View all

Pickled Red Onions
Barrel & Brine
Pickled Red Onions
Sold Out
View
NY Deli Style Pickles
Barrel & Brine
NY Deli Style Pickles
Regular price $7.99
View
Sauerkraut
Barrel & Brine
Sauerkraut
Regular price $7.99
View
Kimchi
Barrel & Brine
Kimchi
Regular price $7.99
View

Battistoni

View all

Uncured Pepperoni
Battistoni
Uncured Pepperoni
Regular price $6.49
View
Pepperoni
Battistoni
Pepperoni
Sold Out
View
Pepperoni Snack Sticks
Battistoni
Pepperoni Snack Sticks
Regular price $4.99
View
Pizza Style Uncured Pepperoni
Battistoni
Pizza Style Uncured Pepperoni
Sold Out
View

Bean Bastard

View all

Coffee Dad
Bean Bastard
Coffee Dad
Regular price $15.99
View
RedRum
Bean Bastard
RedRum
Sold Out
View
Coffee Mom
Bean Bastard
Coffee Mom
Regular price $15.99
View
Midnight
Bean Bastard
Midnight
Regular price $15.99
View

Bee's Gold Raw Honey

View all

Bees’ Gold Creamy Wildflower Honey
Bee's Gold
Bees’ Gold Creamy Wildflower Honey
Sold Out
View
Bees’ Gold Summer Honey
Bee's Gold
Bees’ Gold Summer Honey
Regular price $12
View
Bees’ Gold Wildflower Honey
Bee's Gold
Bees’ Gold Wildflower Honey
Sold Out
View

Biscotti For Everybotti

View all

Triple Chocolate
Biscotti For Everybotti
Triple Chocolate
Regular price $7.99
View
Espresso Chocolate Chip
Biscotti For Everybotti
Espresso Chocolate Chip
Regular price $7.99
View
Coconut Chocolate Chip Biscotti
Biscotti For Everybotti
Coconut Chocolate Chip Biscotti
Regular price $7.99
View
Ginger
Biscotti For Everybotti
Ginger
Regular price $7.99
View

Bloom and Rose Knishes

View all

Traditional Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Bloom and Rose Knishes
Traditional Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
Spinach & Feta Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Bloom and Rose Knishes
Spinach & Feta Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $3.99
View
Smoked Onion and Farmer Cheese Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Bloom and Rose Knishes
Smoked Onion and Farmer Cheese Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
Samosa Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Bloom and Rose Knishes
Samosa Knish (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View

Blue Table Chocolates

View all

Boozy Truffles
Blue Table Chocolates
Boozy Truffles
From $11.99
View
Sampler Box 6-12 pc
Blue Table Chocolates
Sampler Box 6-12 pc
From $9.99
View

Buffalo Pepper Products

View all

Hertel Habanero
Buffalo Pepper Products
Hertel Habanero
Regular price $5.99
View
Main St. Hot
Buffalo Pepper Products
Main St. Hot
Regular price $5.99
View
Ghost Pepper Salsa
Buffalo Pepper Products
Ghost Pepper Salsa
Sold Out
View
BPP Hot Wing Sauce
Buffalo Pepper Products
BPP Hot Wing Sauce
Regular price $6.99
View

Buffalo Tom’s Gourmet Hot Sauce

View all

Buffalo Tom Gourmet Hot Sauce
Buffalo Tom's Hot Sauce
Buffalo Tom Gourmet Hot Sauce
Regular price $8.99
View

Burning Asphalt

View all

Loganberry BBQ Sauce
Burning Asphalt
Loganberry BBQ Sauce
Regular price $7.99
View
Bacon Ketchup
Burning Asphalt
Bacon Ketchup
Regular price $7.99
View
Peach Bourbon BBQ Sauce
Burning Asphalt
Peach Bourbon BBQ Sauce
Regular price $7.99
View
Apple Pie Moonshine BBQ Sauce
Burning Asphalt
Apple Pie Moonshine BBQ Sauce
Regular price $7.99
View

Carrubba's Chicken Pit

View all

Carrubba's Garlic Butter
Carrubba's Chicken Pit
Carrubba's Garlic Butter
Regular price $6.99
View

Chenez's Popcorn

View all

Chocolate Covered Cherry
Chenez's Popcorn
Chocolate Covered Cherry
Sold Out
View
Buffalo Cheddar
Chenez's Popcorn
Buffalo Cheddar
Sold Out
View
Birthday Cake
Chenez's Popcorn
Birthday Cake
Sold Out
View
Caramel
Chenez's Popcorn
Caramel
Sold Out
View

Clarky's Twisted Sauce

View all

Original Twisted Sauce
Clarky's Twisted Sauce
Original Twisted Sauce
Regular price $7.49
View
Red Garlic Parmesan Twisted Sauce
Clarky's Twisted Sauce
Red Garlic Parmesan Twisted Sauce
Regular price $7.49
View
Spicy Twisted Sauce
Clarky's Twisted Sauce
Spicy Twisted Sauce
Regular price $7.49
View
Mild Twisted Sauce
Clarky's Twisted Sauce
Mild Twisted Sauce
Regular price $7.49
View

Cosimano & Ferrari

View all

Tuscan Herb
Cosimano & Ferrari
Tuscan Herb
Regular price $11.99
View
Double Garlic
Cosimano & Ferrari
Double Garlic
Regular price $11.99
View
Garlic Jalapeno
Cosimano & Ferrari
Garlic Jalapeno
Regular price $11.99
View
Pesto
Cosimano & Ferrari
Pesto
Regular price $11.99
View

Cuba Cheese Shoppe

View all

Port Wine Cheese Spread
Cuba Cheese Shoppe
Port Wine Cheese Spread
Regular price $5.49 Sale price $3.99
Sale
View
Sharp Cheddar Cheese Spread
Cuba Cheese Shoppe
Sharp Cheddar Cheese Spread
Regular price $5.49 Sale price $3.99
Sale
View
Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread
Cuba Cheese Shoppe
Garden Vegetable Cheese Spread
Regular price $5.49 Sale price $3.99
Sale
View
Horseradish Cheese Spread
Cuba Cheese Shoppe
Horseradish Cheese Spread
Regular price $5.49 Sale price $3.99
Sale
View

Cuccidati Inc.

View all

1/4 lb Box
Cuccidati Inc.
1/4 lb Box
Regular price $4.99
View
1/2 lb Box
Cuccidati Inc.
1/2 lb Box
Sold Out
View
1 lb Box
Cuccidati Inc.
1 lb Box
Sold Out
View

Cuppa Culture TEApourium

View all

Organic Coconut Chai
Cuppa Culture TEApourium
Organic Coconut Chai
Sold Out
View
Balmoral Breakfast Blend
Cuppa Culture TEApourium
Balmoral Breakfast Blend
Sold Out
View
Organic Ayurvedic SereniTEA
Cuppa Culture TEApourium
Organic Ayurvedic SereniTEA
Sold Out
View
Organic Green Lady Grey
Cuppa Culture TEApourium
Organic Green Lady Grey
Sold Out
View

Dark Forest Chocolate

View all

Coffee And Dark Chocolate
Dark Forest Chocolate
Coffee And Dark Chocolate
Regular price $8.49
View
Excelsior Dark Chocolate
Dark Forest Chocolate
Excelsior Dark Chocolate
Regular price $8.49
View
Goat Milk Chocolate
Dark Forest Chocolate
Goat Milk Chocolate
Regular price $8.49
View
Dark Madagascar Chocolate
Dark Forest Chocolate
Dark Madagascar Chocolate
Sold Out
View

Deb's Delights

View all

Bread & Butter Pickles
Deb's Delights
Bread & Butter Pickles
Sold Out
View
Dilly Beans
Deb's Delights
Dilly Beans
Regular price $10.99
View
Pickled Beets
Deb's Delights
Pickled Beets
From $10.99
View
Old Fashioned Dill Pickles
Deb's Delights
Old Fashioned Dill Pickles
Sold Out
View

Deedee Desserts

View all

Chocolate Mousse
Deedee Desserts
Chocolate Mousse
Regular price $5.99
View
English Toffee
Deedee Desserts
English Toffee
Regular price $5.99
View
Raspberry
Deedee Desserts
Raspberry
Regular price $5.99
View
Lemon Chiffon
Deedee Desserts
Lemon Chiffon
Regular price $5.99
View

Donna's Pepper Jelly & Jams

View all

Blackberry Blueberry
Donna's Jelly & Jams
Blackberry Blueberry
Regular price $6.99
View
Mango Peach
Donna's Jelly & Jams
Mango Peach
Sold Out
View
Cherry Jelly
Donna's Jelly & Jams
Cherry Jelly
Regular price $6.99
View
Blackberry Orange
Donna's Jelly & Jams
Blackberry Orange
Sold Out
View

Dragonfly Jams and Jellies

View all

Cherry Amaretto
Dragonfly Jams and Jellies
Cherry Amaretto
Regular price $8.99
View
Spicy Mango Tango
Dragonfly Jams and Jellies
Spicy Mango Tango
Regular price $8.99
View
Red Raspberry
Dragonfly Jams and Jellies
Red Raspberry
Sold Out
View
Caramel Apple
Dragonfly Jams and Jellies
Caramel Apple
Regular price $8.99
View

Eden Valley Creamery

View all

Garlic Cheese Curds
Eden Valley Creamery
Garlic Cheese Curds
Sold Out
View
Original Cheese Curds
Eden Valley Creamery
Original Cheese Curds
Sold Out
View
Buffalo Cheese Curds
Eden Valley Creamery
Buffalo Cheese Curds
Sold Out
View
Horseradish Cheese Curds
Eden Valley Creamery
Horseradish Cheese Curds
Sold Out
View

Famous Broadway Market Horseradish

View all

Horseradish
Famous Broadway Market Horseradish
Horseradish
Regular price $5.99
View
Horseradish Mustard
Famous Broadway Market Horseradish
Horseradish Mustard
Regular price $5.99
View
Horseradish With Beets
Famous Broadway Market Horseradish
Horseradish With Beets
Regular price $5.99
View
Horseradish Cocktail Sauce
Famous Broadway Market Horseradish
Horseradish Cocktail Sauce
Regular price $5.99
View

Fetch

View all

Peanut Butter Goodness
Fetch Dog Treats
Peanut Butter Goodness
Regular price $6.99
View
Scrumptious Pumpkin
Fetch Dog Treats
Scrumptious Pumpkin
Regular price $6.99
View
Dipped Peanut Butter Bones
Fetch Dog Treats
Dipped Peanut Butter Bones
Regular price $1.99
View
Cheesy Bacon
Fetch Dog Treats
Cheesy Bacon
Sold Out
View

Finger Lakes Harvest

View all

Turmeric Tonic -16oz
Finger Lakes Harvest
Turmeric Tonic -16oz
Regular price $12.99
View
Tart Cherry Tonic - 16oz
Finger Lakes Harvest
Tart Cherry Tonic - 16oz
Regular price $12.99
View
Elderberry Tonic - 16oz
Finger Lakes Harvest
Elderberry Tonic - 16oz
Regular price $12.99
View
Ginger Tonic - 16oz
Finger Lakes Harvest
Ginger Tonic - 16oz
Regular price $12.99
View

Gondola Macaroni Products

View all

Lobster Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Gondola Macaroni Products
Lobster Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $7.99
View
Cheese Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Gondola Macaroni Products
Cheese Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $4.99
View
Jumbo Stuffed Shells with Spinach (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Gondola Macaroni Products
Jumbo Stuffed Shells with Spinach (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $9.99
View
Jumbo Stuffed Shells (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Gondola Macaroni Products
Jumbo Stuffed Shells (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $9.99
View

Go Veggies

View all

Spicy Mushroom Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Go Veggies
Spicy Mushroom Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
Fitness Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Go Veggies
Fitness Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
Lentil Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Go Veggies
Lentil Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $5.99
View
Black Bean Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Go Veggies
Black Bean Burger (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $5.99
View

Gramma Mora's Mexican Cuisine

View all

Gramma Mora's
Gramma Mora's Chorizo & Cheese Burrito (Local Delivery/Pickup only)
Regular price $3.99
View
Gramma Mora's
Gramma Mora's Chicken & Bean Burrito (Local Delivery/Pickup only)
Regular price $3.99
View
Gramma Mora's
Gramma Mora's Bean & Cheese Burrito (Local Delivery/Pickup only)
Regular price $3.99
View
Gramma Mora's
Gramma Mora's Bean & Rice Burrito (Local Delivery/Pickup only)
Regular price $3.99
View

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauces

View all

Rosa Sauce
Guglielmo's Pasta Sauces
Rosa Sauce
Sold Out
View
Home Grown Marinara Sauce
Guglielmo's Pasta Sauces
Home Grown Marinara Sauce
Regular price $6.99
View
Spicy Chunky Veggie
Guglielmo's Pasta Sauces
Spicy Chunky Veggie
Regular price $6.99
View
Sunday Sauce With Ground Beef & Sausage
Guglielmo's Pasta Sauces
Sunday Sauce With Ground Beef & Sausage
Regular price $6.99
View

Healthy Rican

View all

Healthy Rican Adobo
Healthy Rican
Healthy Rican Adobo
Regular price $8.99
View
Healthy Rican Sazon
Healthy Rican
Healthy Rican Sazon
Regular price $8.99
View
Sofrito
Healthy Rican
Sofrito
Regular price $8.99
View

Issa's Flame Baked Pita Chips

View all

Za'atar + Thyme
Issa's Pita Chips
Za'atar + Thyme
Regular price $3.49
View
Cinnamon Sugar
Issa's Pita Chips
Cinnamon Sugar
Regular price $3.49
View
Classic
Issa's Pita Chips
Classic
Sold Out
View
Whole Wheat
Issa's Pita Chips
Whole Wheat
Sold Out
View

Jake and the Fatman BBQ

View all

Fatman BBQ Rib Rub
Jake and the Fatman BBQ
Fatman BBQ Rib Rub
Regular price $7.99
View

Jeca Energy Bars

View all

Kelly's Country Store

View all

Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy
Kelly's Country Store
Milk Chocolate Sponge Candy
Sold Out
View
Orange Chocolate Sponge Candy
Kelly's Country Store
Orange Chocolate Sponge Candy
Sold Out
View
Dark Chocolate Sponge Candy
Kelly's Country Store
Dark Chocolate Sponge Candy
Regular price $11.99
View

Keeping Tradtions Pierogi

View all

Farmer Cheese Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Keeping Traditions Pierogi
Farmer Cheese Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $11.99
View
Smoke N Bacon Cheddar & Potato
Keeping Traditions Pierogi
Smoke N Bacon Cheddar & Potato
Regular price $11.99
View
Mozzarella and Ricotta Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Keeping Traditions Pierogi
Mozzarella and Ricotta Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $11.99
View
Cheese Stuffed Banana Pepper Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Keeping Traditions Pierogi
Cheese Stuffed Banana Pepper Pierogi (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $11.99
View

Kissed By The Sun Spices

View all

everything bagel seasoning
Kissed by the Sun
Everything Bagel Seasoning
From $5.99
View
Seasoned Sea Salt
Kissed by the Sun
Seasoned Sea Salt
From $5.99
View
Sweet & Hot Peppers
Kissed by the Sun
Sweet & Hot Peppers
From $5.99
View
KISSED BY THE SUN HOLIDAY GIFT BOX
Kissed by the Sun
KISSED BY THE SUN HOLIDAY GIFT BOX
Regular price $35.94 Sale price $30
Sale
View

Laura's Raw Honey

View all

Wildflower
Laura's Raw Honey
Wildflower
From $14.99
View
Whipped Honey with Lemon
Laura's Raw Honey
Whipped Honey with Lemon
Regular price $14.99
View
Laura's Raw Honey
Whipped Honey with Cinnamon
Regular price $17.99
View
Whipped Honey with Chai
Laura's Raw Honey
Whipped Honey with Chai
Regular price $17.99
View

Lewiston's Jams & Jellies

View all

Ghost Pepper
Lewiston Jams & Jellies
Ghost Pepper
Regular price $4.99
View
Raspberry Jalapeno
Lewiston Jams & Jellies
Raspberry Jalapeno
Regular price $4.99
View
Triple Berry Jam
Lewiston Jams & Jellies
Triple Berry Jam
Regular price $4.99
View
Lake Breeze Blueberry
Lewiston Jams & Jellies
Lake Breeze Blueberry
Regular price $4.99
View

Life Itself

View all

Wild Chaga Mushroom Tea
life itself
Wild Chaga Mushroom Tea
Sold Out
View

Lions Mane Infusions

View all

Mushroom Tincture
Lions Mane
Mushroom Tincture
Regular price $29.99
View

Malezewski Butter Lambs

View all

Butter Lamb 4oz (Local Pickup/Delivery)
Malezewski Butter Lambs
Butter Lamb 4oz (Local Pickup/Delivery)
Regular price $3.99
View
Butter Lamb 6oz (Local Pickup/Delivery)
Malezewski Butter Lambs
Butter Lamb 6oz (Local Pickup/Delivery)
Regular price $5.99
View

Maple Glen Sugarhouse

View all

8oz Pure Maple Syrup
Maple Glen Sugarhouse
8oz Pure Maple Syrup
Sold Out
View
Bourbon Barrel Aged 200ml Collector's Pure Maple Syrup
Maple Glen Sugarhouse
Bourbon Barrel Aged 200ml Collector's Pure Maple Syrup
Regular price $9.99
View
12oz Pure Maple Syrup
Maple Glen Sugarhouse
12oz Pure Maple Syrup
Regular price $11.99
View
Squeezable Pure Maple Syrup
Maple Glen Sugarhouse
Squeezable Pure Maple Syrup
Regular price $11.99
View

McDuffie's Bakery

View all

Toffee Crunch Shortbread Cookies
McDuffie's Bakery
Toffee Crunch Shortbread Cookies
Regular price $4.99
View
Traditional Shortbread Cookies
McDuffie's Bakery
Traditional Shortbread Cookies
Regular price $4.99
View
Butterscotch Shortbread Cookies
McDuffie's Bakery
Butterscotch Shortbread Cookies
Regular price $4.99
View
White Chocolate Cranberry Shortbread Cookies
McDuffie's Bakery
White Chocolate Cranberry Shortbread Cookies
Sold Out
View

Meyer's Homegrown Popcorn

View all

Red White & Blue Popcorn
Meyer's Homegrown Popcorn
Red White & Blue Popcorn
Regular price $5.99
View
White Popcorn
Meyer's Homegrown Popcorn
White Popcorn
Sold Out
View
Blue Popcorn
Meyer's Homegrown Popcorn
Blue Popcorn
Regular price $5.99
View
Blue & Yellow
Meyer's Homegrown Popcorn
Blue & Yellow
Sold Out
View

M&M Pickles

View all

Najah

View all

Hot Fenugreek and Date Dip
Najah Sauces
Hot Fenugreek and Date Dip
Regular price $6.99
View
Mild Fenugreek and Date Dip
Najah Sauces
Mild Fenugreek and Date Dip
Regular price $6.99
View
Hot Tamarind Sauce
Najah Sauces
Hot Tamarind Sauce
Regular price $6.99
View
Najah Chai Tea
Najah Sauces
Najah Chai Tea
From $12.49
View

Nanny Dot's Pantry

View all

Nanny Dot's Bacon Onion Jam
Nanny Dot's Pantry
Nanny Dot's Bacon Onion Jam
Sold Out
View
Nanny Dot's Garlicy Pepper Relish
Nanny Dot's Pantry
Nanny Dot's Garlicy Pepper Relish
Sold Out
View
Nanny Dot's Bacon Dressing
Nanny Dot's Pantry
Nanny Dot's Bacon Dressing
Sold Out
View
Nanny Dot's Spicy Pepper Relish
Nanny Dot's Pantry
Nanny Dot's Spicy Pepper Relish
Sold Out
View

New Day Coffee

View all

Let’s Go Buffalo Blend
New Day Coffee
Let’s Go Buffalo Blend
Regular price $10.99
View
Morning Blend
New Day Coffee
Morning Blend
Regular price $10.99
View
Colombian Santa Barbara Estate
New Day Coffee
Colombian Santa Barbara Estate
Regular price $10.99
View
Salted Caramel Mocha
New Day Coffee
Salted Caramel Mocha
Regular price $10.99
View

New York Chips

View all

Anchor Bar
New York Chips
Anchor Bar
Regular price $3.99
View
Wavy Sea Salt
New York Chips
Wavy Sea Salt
Sold Out
View
Spiedie Chips
New York Chips
Spiedie Chips
Regular price $3.99
View
Wavy Salt & Vinegar
New York Chips
Wavy Salt & Vinegar
Sold Out
View

Nickel City Alchemy

View all

Sleep Balm
Nickel City Alchemy
Sleep Balm
Sold Out
View
Recovery Balm
Nickel City Alchemy
Recovery Balm
Regular price $17.99
View
Immunity Balm
Nickel City Alchemy
Immunity Balm
Regular price $17.99
View
Sleep Magnesium Salt Soak
Nickel City Alchemy
Sleep Magnesium Salt Soak
Regular price $8.99
View

Nickel City Nitro

View all

Nitro Cold Brew
Nickel City Nitro
Nitro Cold Brew
Regular price $4.99
View

Nick's Spider Venom

View all

Death Sauce
Nick's Spider Venom
Death Sauce
Regular price $5.99
View
Single Bite
Nick's Spider Venom
Single Bite
Regular price $5.99
View
Double Bite
Nick's Spider Venom
Double Bite
Regular price $5.99
View
Triple Bite
Nick's Spider Venom
Triple Bite
Sold Out
View

Nunda Mustard

View all

Honey Brew
Nunda Mustard
Honey Brew
Regular price $5.99
View
Horseradish Caraway
Nunda Mustard
Horseradish Caraway
Regular price $5.99
View
Cajun Onion
Nunda Mustard
Cajun Onion
Regular price $5.99
View
Smokey Maple
Nunda Mustard
Smokey Maple
Regular price $5.99
View

Park Edge Sweet Shop

View all

Milk Sponge Candy
Park Edge Sweet Shop
Milk Sponge Candy
Regular price $10.99
View
Orange Sponge Candy
Park Edge Sweet Shop
Orange Sponge Candy
Regular price $10.99
View
Dark Sponge Candy
Park Edge Sweet Shop
Dark Sponge Candy
Regular price $10.99
View

Pasta Peddler

View all

Stuffed Hot Pepper Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Pasta Peddler
Stuffed Hot Pepper Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
Tomato Burgundy
Pasta Peddler
Tomato Burgundy
Regular price $6.99
View
Spinach Cheese Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Pasta Peddler
Spinach Cheese Ravioli (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $8.49
View
Garlic Onion Linguine
Pasta Peddler
Garlic Onion Linguine
Regular price $3.99
View

Penelope's Dog Treats

View all

Peanut Butter Pumpkin Treats
Penelope's Treats
Peanut Butter Pumpkin Treats
Regular price $9.99
View
Sweet Potato Carrot Treats
Penelope's Treats
Sweet Potato Carrot Treats
Regular price $9.99
View
Apple Bacon Cheddar Treats
Penelope's Treats
Apple Bacon Cheddar Treats
Regular price $9.99
View

Pickle Annie's

View all

Buffalo Spirit
Pickle Annie's
Buffalo Spirit
Sold Out
View
E.A. 1850 Dressing
Pickle Annie's
E.A. 1850 Dressing
Sold Out
View
Sunday Breakfast
Pickle Annie's
Sunday Breakfast
Sold Out
View
Grandma's French Dressing
Pickle Annie's
Grandma's French Dressing
Sold Out
View

Pizza Plant

View all

Pepperoni and Sausage Pod (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Pizza Plant
Pepperoni and Sausage Pod (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
White Pod (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Pizza Plant
White Pod (Local Delivery/Pickup)
Sold Out
View
Gluten-Free Flour
Pizza Plant
Gluten-Free Flour
Regular price $7.49
View

That Popcorn Shack

View all

Dill Pickle
Popcorn Shack
Dill Pickle
Regular price $5.99
View
Salt n' Vinegar
Popcorn Shack
Salt n' Vinegar
Regular price $5.99
View
Wannabe Wisconsin White Cheddar
Popcorn Shack
Wannabe Wisconsin White Cheddar
Regular price $5.99
View
Caramel Crunch Cashew
Popcorn Shack
Caramel Crunch Cashew
Regular price $5.99
View

Salvatores Speciality Foods

View all

Pizza Sauce
Salvatores Speciality Foods
Pizza Sauce
Regular price $6.99
View
Salvatores Pizza Dough Mix
Salvatores Speciality Foods
Salvatores Pizza Dough Mix
Regular price $6.99
View
Salvatores Sweet & Spicy Salsa
Salvatores Speciality Foods
Salvatores Sweet & Spicy Salsa
Regular price $6.99
View

Smita's Cookery

View all

Smita's Vegetable Spice
Smita's Cookery
Smita's Vegetable Spice
Regular price $6.49
View
Smita's Meat Spice
Smita's Cookery
Smita's Meat Spice
Regular price $6.49
View

View all

Snowy Owl Kombucha

View all

Tart Cherry Vanilla
Snowy Owl Kombucha
Tart Cherry Vanilla
Regular price $3.99
View
Ultraviolet
Snowy Owl Kombucha
Ultraviolet
Regular price $3.99
View
Raspberry Mosaic Hops
Snowy Owl Kombucha
Raspberry Mosaic Hops
Regular price $3.99
View
Lemon Ginger Black Pepper Turmeric
Snowy Owl Kombucha
Lemon Ginger Black Pepper Turmeric
Regular price $3.99
View

So Good Granola

View all

Blueberry Pizzazz Granola
So Good Granola
Blueberry Pizzazz Granola
Regular price $11.99
View
FEATURE FLAVOR - Besties Granola
So Good Granola
FEATURE FLAVOR - Besties Granola
Regular price $11.99
View
Ms. Goodbar Granola
So Good Granola
Ms. Goodbar Granola
Regular price $11.99
View
Buffalo Wing Granola
So Good Granola
Buffalo Wing Granola
Regular price $11.99
View

Spices by Milly

View all

BLT Dip
Spices by Milly
BLT Dip
Sold Out
View
Spinach Mix Dip
Spices by Milly
Spinach Mix Dip
Regular price $3.99
View
Dill Dip
Spices by Milly
Dill Dip
Regular price $3.99
View
Garlic and Herb Dip
Spices by Milly
Garlic and Herb Dip
Regular price $3.99
View

Spoonfuls Gourmet Nut Butters

View all

Divine Goodness
Spoonfuls Gourmet Nut Butters
Divine Goodness
Regular price $7.99
View
Chunky Monkey
Spoonfuls Gourmet Nut Butters
Chunky Monkey
Regular price $7.99
View
All The Fixings
Spoonfuls Gourmet Nut Butters
All The Fixings
Regular price $7.99
View
Bees For Breakfast
Spoonfuls Gourmet Nut Butters
Bees For Breakfast
Regular price $7.99
View

Sugarcane WNY

View all

Sugarcane Apple Butter
Sugarcane WNY
Sugarcane Apple Butter
Regular price $7.99
View
Sugarcane Peach Butter
Sugarcane WNY
Sugarcane Peach Butter
Regular price $7.99
View
Sugarcane Sugar 10oz
Sugarcane WNY
Sugarcane Sugar 10oz
Sold Out
View
Sugarcane Sugar 16oz
Sugarcane WNY
Sugarcane Sugar 16oz
Regular price $9.99
View

Tea-Licious Trendz

View all

Fireside Spark Tea
Tea-Licious Trendz
Fireside Spark Tea
Sold Out
View
French Raspberry
Tea-Licious Trendz
French Raspberry
Sold Out
View
Cinnamon Snuggler Tea
Tea-Licious Trendz
Cinnamon Snuggler Tea
Sold Out
View
Parisian Red Elixir Tea
Tea-Licious Trendz
Parisian Red Elixir Tea
Sold Out
View

Ted's Hot Dogs

View all

Ted's Famous Hot Sauce
Ted's Hot Dogs
Ted's Famous Hot Sauce
Regular price $4.99
View
Ted's Aioli Burger Sauce
Ted's Hot Dogs
Ted's Aioli Burger Sauce
Regular price $4.99
View
Ted's Everything Sauce
Ted's Hot Dogs
Ted's Everything Sauce
Regular price $4.99
View
Ted's Zesty Mustard
Ted's Hot Dogs
Ted's Zesty Mustard
Regular price $4.99
View

That Popcorn Shack

View all

Dill Pickle
Popcorn Shack
Dill Pickle
Regular price $5.99
View
Salt n' Vinegar
Popcorn Shack
Salt n' Vinegar
Regular price $5.99
View
Wannabe Wisconsin White Cheddar
Popcorn Shack
Wannabe Wisconsin White Cheddar
Regular price $5.99
View
Caramel Crunch Cashew
Popcorn Shack
Caramel Crunch Cashew
Regular price $5.99
View

The Blend Bar

View all

Crispy Rice
The Blend Bar
Crispy Rice
Regular price $3.49
View
Peanut Butter & Jelly
The Blend Bar
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Sold Out
View
Sunbutter
The Blend Bar
Sunbutter
Sold Out
View
Salted Caramel
The Blend Bar
Salted Caramel
Regular price $3.49
View

The Sweet Whisk

View all

S'mores Bar
Sweet Whisk
S'mores Bar
From $3.25
View
Hazlenut Crunch
Sweet Whisk
Hazlenut Crunch
From $3.25
View
Cookies & Cream
Sweet Whisk
Cookies & Cream
From $3.25
View
White Chocolate Peppermint Bar
Sweet Whisk
White Chocolate Peppermint Bar
On sale from $2.25
Sale
View

Top Seedz

View all

Sea Salt Crackers
Top Seedz
Sea Salt Crackers
Regular price $7.99
View
6 Seed Crackers
Top Seedz
6 Seed Crackers
Regular price $7.99
View
Rosemary Crackers
Top Seedz
Rosemary Crackers
Regular price $7.99
View
Roasted Seeds Maple Magic
Top Seedz
Roasted Seeds Maple Magic
Regular price $7.99
View

Uncle Bob's BBQ Sauce

View all

Uncle Bob's BBQ Sauce
Uncle Bob's BBQ
Uncle Bob's BBQ Sauce
Regular price $4.99
View

Weber's Maple Products

View all

Pure Maple Syrup - Pint
Weber's Maple Products
Pure Maple Syrup - Pint
Sold Out
View
Pure Maple Syrup - Quart
Weber's Maple Products
Pure Maple Syrup - Quart
Sold Out
View
Buttermilk Pancake Mix
Weber's Maple Products
Buttermilk Pancake Mix
Regular price $5.99
View
Apple Cinnamon Pancake Mix
Weber's Maple Products
Apple Cinnamon Pancake Mix
Sold Out
View

Weber's Mustard

View all

Weber's Horseradish Mustard
Weber's Mustard
Weber's Horseradish Mustard
From $3.49
View
Weber's Spicy Dill Relish 6oz
Weber's Mustard
Weber's Spicy Dill Relish 6oz
Regular price $3.49
View
Weber's Hot Piccalilli Relish 6oz
Weber's Mustard
Weber's Hot Piccalilli Relish 6oz
Regular price $3.49
View
Weber's Hot Garlic Mustard
Weber's Mustard
Weber's Hot Garlic Mustard
Regular price $3.49
View

We R Nuts

View all

Bourbon Butter Pecan
We R Nuts
Bourbon Butter Pecan
Sold Out
View
English Toffee Cashews
We R Nuts
English Toffee Cashews
Sold Out
View
Cinnamon Almond
We R Nuts
Cinnamon Almond
Sold Out
View
Honey Cashew
We R Nuts
Honey Cashew
Regular price $8.99
View

What's Pop-In' Gourmet Popcorn

View all

Mexican Street Corn
What's Pop-In' Gourmet Popcorn
Mexican Street Corn
Sold Out
View
Pickle
What's Pop-In' Gourmet Popcorn
Pickle
Regular price $5.99
View
Garlic Parm
What's Pop-In' Gourmet Popcorn
Garlic Parm
Regular price $5.99
View
Salt & Vinegar
What's Pop-In' Gourmet Popcorn
Salt & Vinegar
Regular price $5.99
View

Yancey's Fancey

View all

Champagne
Yancey's Fancy Cheese
Champagne
Regular price $5.99
View
Steakhouse Onion
Yancey's Fancy Cheese
Steakhouse Onion
Regular price $5.99
View
Smoked Gouda
Yancey's Fancy Cheese
Smoked Gouda
Regular price $5.99
View
Fresh Killer Dill
Yancey's Fancy Cheese
Fresh Killer Dill
Sold Out
View

Yeah! Vegan Pierogi

View all

Yeah Pierogi
Yeah! Poblano Black Bean Pierogi (Vegan)(Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $9.99
View
Yeah Pierogi
Yeah! Potato & Cheeze Pierogi (Vegan)(Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $9.99
View
Yeah Pierogi
Yeah! Sauerkraut & Onion Pierogi (Vegan)(Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $9.99
View
Yeah Pierogi
Yeah! Buffalo Chickpea Pierogi (Vegan)(Local Delivery/Pickup)
Regular price $9.99
View

View all

Menu

  • Search
  • Online Shop
  • Meet The Makers
  • Outdoor Market Applications
  • Return Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us

Follow us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

Contact Us

Northtowns Plaza 

4558 N. Bailey Avenue 

Amherst, NY, 14226

E: hello@wnyfoodtraders.com

P: 716-322-7122

Be in the know

© 2022, Buffalo Artisan Food Traders . All Rights Reserved.
Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Facebook Pay
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Press the space key then arrow keys to make a selection.
  • Use left/right arrows to navigate the slideshow or swipe left/right if using a mobile device